Why was Antonio Sanchez' Birdman score disqualified for an Oscar?
The answers the Academy gave for their extremely peculiar decision disagree with the facts. The Academy reasons for disqualification are below, followed by the facts.
Academy: The biggest dramatic moments of the film were underscored by classical music. This dilutes the original score.
• Fact: The most memorable moments are scored by drums:
—Riggan’s attempt at suicide onstage
—His tormented destruction of his dressing room
—The most climactic moments of the film
• Fact: The classical music is not part of the score—it was part of the play and the events in the movie.
• Fact: The King's Speech score (nomination, 2010) was not disqualified, even though classical music not written by the film composer played a huge role in the film.
• Fact: The score for The Artist was nominated and won the Oscar in 2012 despite the climactic scene being underscored by music lifted directly from Bernard Hermann's score for Vertigo.
Academy: Over 50% of the score is sourced music, not written by the composer.
• Fact: Birdman has over 30 minutes of Sanchez' original score and only 17 minutes of sourced music.
• Fact: The Full Monty (nomination, 1997) was not disqualified, even though it had over 34 minutes of songs—twice as much as Birdman.
• Fact: Slumdog Millionaire (nomination, 2008) was not disqualified, even though it was full of songs.
The facts contradict what the Academy said, and we have the following questions:
• When the Academy decided to disqualify the score for Birdman, were the members aware of previous Academy decisions that qualified The Artist, The King’s Speech, The Full Monty, Slumdog Millionaire and others?
• Is the music branch of the Academy aware that their application of qualification rules is markedly inconsistent?
We feel that the Academy is wrong on this one. Their decision on Birdman makes no sense in light of the precedents.
We hope the Academy will apply its rules consistently going forward, to ensure that creative and innovative work is always acknowledged and encouraged, and all contenders can be sure the Awards are fairly and impartially given.
Christian Contact the author of the petition
Our users have bought extra visibility to these petitions
- Support the Romanian Tax incentive law - Tax incentives for film productions have been in place in countries around the world for 20 years and Romania is not yet part of this global system!! Since 2003, most European Union countries, have put in place financial support programs for the film industry and thus attracting millions of Euros in foreign investments (the Czech Republic, Croatia, France, Germany,...
- Boycott Tesco over Muslim Advert - Tesco have deliberately included a Muslim family in an advertisement about Christmas 2017. 'However you do Christmas, we've got a turkey for you,' goes the ad. But we the undersigned note: (a) Christmas is a Christian festival,(b) God became flesh in Jesus Christ and dwelt among us,(c) Muslims deny the truth of the Incarnation,(d) Tesco do not even (thank God) sell hal...
We provide free hosting for online petitions. Create a professional online petition by using our powerful service. Our petitions are mentioned in the media every day, so creating a petition is a great way to get noticed by the public and the decision makers.
Follow us on Facebook
Most Popular Petitions
|30 days||All time||Petition name||Created|
|3 248||3 261|| Save Nuntii Latini, the world’s only weekly Latin language news broadcast!
Save Nuntii Latini, the world’s only weekly Latin language news broadcast! We demand that the Finnish Broadcasting Company YLE should continue its Latin language news. For over 28 years a small group of dedicated Finnish Latinists has produced a news program which is a testament to the vitality and flexibility of Latin. It is a unique phenomenon that unites language enthusiasts – from expert...
|3 195||3 204|| Support the Romanian Tax incentive law
Tax incentives for film productions have been in place in countries around the world for 20 years and Romania is not yet part of this global system!! Since 2003, most European Union countries, have put in place financial support programs for the film industry and thus attracting millions of Euros in foreign investments (the Czech Republic, Croatia, France, Germany, Iceland, Italy, the UK, Hungary...
|1 809||1 813|| Contre la démolition des pensions de l'enseignement / Tegen de afbraak van het onderwijspensioen
[NL] ( [FR]: la version en français se trouve en bas) Petitie tegen de afbraak van het onderwijspensioen (België) Langer werken voor minder pensioen? Niet te doen! Weinig sectoren zijn zo zwaar getroffen door de pensioenhervormingen als het onderwijs. Leerkrachten die aan het begin van hun loopbaan staan, zullen 5 tot 8 jaar langer moeten werken en als alle geplande maatregelen uitgevoerd wo...
|760||762|| Against the killing of street dogs in Smolyan
In an interview in the local newspaper, related to the street dogs, the mayor of Smolyan informed the public that he will deal with this problem within two weeks. Everyone familiar with the case is aware that this problem could not be solved within days unless it is approached radically, which would be illegal. Let's not forget that in 2012 in Smolyan municipality, dozens of street...
|651||656|| HELP Reinstitute the Ban on Importing the Heads of Hunted Elephants
In an appalling turn of events, the Trump administration confirmed Thursday that it lifted a ban that had prohibited hunters from importing trophies of elephants killed in two African nations, reversing a 2014 rule put in place by the Obama White House. The reversal will apply to elephants hunted in Zimbabwe from Jan. 21, 2016 to Dec. 31, 2018 and to elephants hunted in Zambia in 2016, 2017 and 20...
|533||533|| We want Robbie Mitchell working back at Walmart
Walmart in Angleton Texas fired him because his van broke down and when he got back to work they fired him for not calling in and he did. Hes been with the company for 22yrs we want him back he's a great guy that deserves better then this ...
|531||531|| ISH free on snowy days
The international school Hilversum is a very diverse school with students from all over the world. The students use several utilities to get to school, E.G. bike, train, bus etc. A lot of these things are hard to use while there is snow outside. That is why I would like you all to sign this petition so that we are free on snowy days like these....
|526||2 023|| Ban Fireworks-South Africa
Due to many animals been harmed and stressed during the New Year's Eve celebrations as well as any other excuse they use to set off fireworks, we need to do more to ban fireworks. A heavy fine should be given if caught in possession or letting off fireworks....
|306||307|| Bluewater Bay NHW I-Patrol Future Existence
Bluewater Bay NHW I-Patrol was dully constituted on the 31st May 2016, following the rules for Voluntary Association formations. We are now being told that we are not compliant due to our failure to accept the Interim Guidelines for NHW's as set out by Safety and Liaison. We therefore need to decide do we disband or should be continue. A post was placed on Facebook on the Bluewater Bay and Amste...
|224||224|| Would you support the 2018-2019 Abu Dhabi National Pro as a competidor, coach, or parent?
Vamos por mas! Firma este petiticion confirmando su apoyo para otro National Pro en 2018. ...
|179||3 656|| Älä ota mikrosirua. VeriChip ei ole ihmiselle tarkoitettu
Älä ota mikrosirua !!!...
|178||586|| Protect North Central Park from Major Development
The Laredo City Council, together with Webb County, voted to move forward with plans for MAJOR development at North Central Park, just south of the Trailhead Facility (see below). They plan to build a veterans museum with warehouse style construction on 2+ acres of land that will require parking, bright security lighting, and other infrastructure that will DRASTICALLY alter the park's natural land...
|169||7 999|| Stop the Nobel Center in Stockholm!
We are against the demolition of highly valued cultural heritage in the heart of Stockholm and believe there are better places for the Nobel Center to be built, if it has to be built at all. The current design of the Center is much too big for the setting, and risks dwarfing one of Sweden's landmark architectural masterpieces, the National Museum of Art. We want to refine the Blasieholmen peninsul...
|168||529|| PLEASE HELP TO STOP MASS SHOOTINGS OF ANIMALS IN ESTONIAN WOODS! (Closed)
Every year hundreds and thousands of wild animals are hunted in Estonian woods. Our request is to address the Environement Office in order to reduce the number of hunted animals and involve experts in hunting policy. Thank you in advance! Estonians who care about the natural environment ...
|164||164|| I call upon Dublin City Council and Ardmhéara Mícheál MacDonncha to award posthumously the Freedom of the City of Dublin that was recently renounced by Bob Geldof to Philip Chevron
Philip (Ryan) Chevron, whom I and so many of you will well remember for his great work with the Radiators, The Pogues, Agnes Bernelle, the Project Arts Centre and so much more. Philip wrote many great songs and created theatrical works that reflected Dublin so well - much more so than Bob I would suggest. The man who wrote Kitty Ricketts and Faithful Departed and Under Clery's Clock and The Ha'pe...
|161||164|| Petition to have the VC and the DUPA head step down from office.
This petition has come as a result of the neglect of the primary stakeholder’s at Daystar university; the students. This follows constant complains by the students through prescribed channels such as “Baraza’s” which has seen consecutive DUSA (Daystar university student association) governments table the same issues to the same Vice chancellor, Dr. Timothy Wachira, for six years to no avail. The s...
|160||161|| Save North Queensland Equestrian Centre
Please sign this petition to save North Queensland Equestrian Centre (Bluewater). Townsville Council has erected a notice to change zoning of the club grounds in order for the council to sell off a portion of the grounds. This in effect will change how the club can operate and improve the grounds. Many hours of hard work and fundraising to improve the club will go down the drain if this is not sto...
|159||159|| Marion County Students being denied Technical Education!
The administration and a select few staff members of North Marion High School are restricting their students to go to Marion County Technical Center (which is physically connected ,but not a part of North Marion High School) during students lunch and free time (with a note from teacher giving permission to go to the Technical Center) to learn and advance in the programs that the Technical Center o...
|159||529|| Statement on Solidarity with "Csíki Játékszín" Theatre
The undersigned, leaders of Hungarian Theatre Union (MASZÍN), leaders of institutions, independent theatre artists, company leaders, and cultural managers, solidary with our collegues from Miercurea Ciuc, it is with great concern that we follow the developments and press articles with reference to Csíki Játékszín Theatre, and especially the phenomenon which gave rise to this situation. Last week,...
|154||154|| سهمیه زنان (Closed)
بسمه تعالی وزیر محترم بهداشت و درمان جناب آقای دکتر قاضی زاده هاشمی ما خانم های مشمول قانون تخصیص سهمیه زنان در امتحان دستیاری، از حضرتعالی تقاضا داریم با توجه به اینکه می توانستیم در رشته خودمان در محل دیگر با سهمیه آزاد قبول شویم و این حق از ما دریغ شد؛ترتیبی اتخاذ فرمایید تا تفاوت ما با کسی که بدون سهمیه قبول نبوده است افتراق داده شود و خواهشمندیم 30 تا 50 درصد از سنوات طرح ما کم شود همچنین در...
|149||149|| fermeture de l'impact Bastia après la soirée de DJKPARIS
Si vous vous êtes retrouvés un minimum CHOQUÉS par ce qu'il s'est passé pendant la soirée organisée par l'Impact de Bastia en collaboration avec DJKPARIS, Si vous voulez protéger vos fils, vos filles des immondicités qui ont été encouragées durant cette soirée, Si vous pensez que la jeunesse corse vaut mieux que le fait de se déshabiller pour une bouteille de vodka, Si vous trouvez honteux le fait...
|147||22 761|| Petition against slaughter and export for slaughter of Polish horses
President PiS Jaroslaw Kaczynski Al.Jerozolimskie 125/127 02-017 Warszawa Prime Minister of the Republic of Poland Beata Szydlo Kancelaria Prezesa Rady Ministrow Aleje Ujazdowskie 1/3 00-583 Warszawa Parliament (Sejm Rzeczpospolitej Polskiej) Kancelaria Sejmu Ul. Wiejska 4/6/8 00-902 Warszawa Honorable Prime Minister, Honorable Members of Parliament, We appeal to you to support the...
|143||144|| Stop Dollar General Corporation from putting in a Dollar General Store in Rainbow Valley!
Let your voices be heard by Joy Rich, Maricopa County Manager, over Planning and Development Department, Darren Gerard, AICP, Deputy Director, Department of Planning and Development, Farhad Tavassoli, Planner, Planning and Development Services and Steve Gallardo, District 5 Board of Supervisor of Maricopa County, Arizona. We the people of the community of Rainbow Valley, Buckeye, Arizona 85326, a...
|132||132|| Protect Read Island public roads from clear cut logging by Island Timberlands LP.
The Read Island public road holds special value to residents as well as visitors and others who care for this place. Therefore: We the undersigned insist that Island Timberlands establish a 100 meter buffer along the Read Island Road. This buffer would include the preservation of roadside forests in an especially sensitive area alongside Fell Creek (aka Earthquake Creek), which is classified as...
|127||209|| Solidarietà al professor Ibrahim Kaboğlu e agli altri “Academics for Peace” che rischiano la condanna da uno a cinque anni di carcere
Solidarietà al professor Ibrahim Kaboğlu e agli altri “Academics for Peace” che rischiano la condanna da uno a cinque anni di carcere I firmatari - accademici, giudici e avvocati italiani - esprimono la loro solidarietà al professor Ibrahim Kaboğlu e agli altri accademici rinviati a giudizio sulla base dell’articolo 7 della legge contro il terrorismo, in quanto sottoscrittori della petizione per...
|123||124|| MISS P NEEDS TO STAY!!!!!!!
SIGN TO HOPEFULLY MAKE MISS P STAY LONGER. JUST LIKE SIGN AND STUFF TO HELP OUT!!!! IF YOU DONT YOU ARE KILLING PUPPIES AND RUINING THE LIVES OF POOR INNOCENT STARVING CHILDREN...
|115||115|| Removing the age restriction on coverage for Insulin pumps
My name is Josh Goldstein, 23, and I'm living with Type 1 Diabetes. Coming this Christmas day I will have been living with this disease for 9 years. In layman's terms, diabetes has to do with the lack of production or the unsuitable production of insulin. For the purpose of this petition I will be focusing on the the first type (type one diabetes) which is the lack or the absolute zero production...
|115||440|| Protect Livanjsko polje!
Livanjsko polje is the largest marsh complex in Bosnia and Herzegovina and the largest temporarily flooded karst polje in the world. Recent research in this area indicates the presence of more than 700 vascular plants, 42 species of dragonflies and damselflies, 39 butterflies, 16 fish species, four of which are exclusively related to karst waters, 6 amphibians, numerous mammals, including a popula...
|113||11 781|| No more Thyroid Madness
Levaxin (synthetic T4) is medicine we thyroid disease offered and many patients are doing very well on it but, there are also many who do not regain their health with Levaxin, which is a synthetic hormone, but feel very bad with persistent symptoms of hypothyroidism or hyperthyroidism. I want this to be illuminated in the medical treatment! These people are today without the help and medicine,...
|107||308|| More vegan food options at WUR
RE: Petition for more vegan food on campus Dear Wageningen University & Research, We, the undersigned, urge Wageningen University & Research to live up to its image as the ‘third most sustainable university in the world’ by providing its students, professors, and other faculty members with more environmentally-friendly food, namely vegan options, on campus. There is a clear consensus on th...
|106||3 555|| The University of Oulu Zoological Museum must be saved
Due to the new Finnish law regulating universities in Finland and due to general pressures of cost cutting and savings, universities and their activities struggle under constant change and cutbacks. An unfortunate consequence is the shutdown of the time-honored and respected University of Oulu Zoological Museum; or it is move to the facilities that are not design for this purpose, and that are not...
|98||98|| Boycott Nestle Products!! The shops are no longer allowed to offer these products!!!
Wir unterstützen keine Unternehmen, die Menschen, Tiere und die Umwelt zerstören !!!! https://www.dailydot.com/via/nestle-california-bottled-water/ https://www.theguardian.com/sustainable-business/nestle-baby-milk-scandal-food-industry-standards http://www.bottledlifefilm.com/index.php/the-story.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/nestle-is-being-sued-for-allegedly-using-child-sl...
|96||96|| Code rood is vrij voor leerlingen voortgezet onderwijs
Sneeuwvrij voor scholieren bij code rood. wanneer het knmi adviseert niet de weg op te gaan geldt dat ook voor scholieren....
|91||92|| პეტიცია ,,ბოლნელის“ გადასარჩენად
ჩვენ, პეტიციის ხელმომწერები მოვითხოვთ შენარჩუნდეს და სრულყოფილად არსებობისა და ფუნქციონირების საშუალება მიეცეს 500 თავდადებული ბოლნელის სახელობის ქ. ბოლნისის ქართული ეროვნული ცეკვების სახალხო ანსამბლ „ბოლნელს“. მივმართავთ საქართველოს კულტურისა და ძეგლთა დაცვის, რეგიონული განვითარებისა და ინფრასტრუქტის სამინისტროებს, აგრეთვე ქვემო ქართლის სამხარეო ადმინისტრაციასა და ბოლნისის მუნიციპალიტეტი...
|90||91|| FAIR HEARING: DATO' DR. AZHAR AMIR HAMZAH (Dept Surgery PPSP)
Assalamualaikum, Dear Dato'/Prof/Assoc Prof/Dr. PPSP Respected Colleagues Trust you are keeping well. We are writing to inform & invite you to join us as members of ONLINE PETITION team to show our solidarity to support one of promising young PPSP/HUSM talents, Dato' Dr.Azhar Amir Hamzah (Dept. of Surgery) for a fair and open hearing subsequent to USM response to an administrative tribu...
|89||89|| Formal Letter of Complaint to SAE Institute.
This petition accompanies an official letter of complaint to SAE Institute demanding the reinstatement of 24-hour access to Bankstock studios at SAE London campus. The letter reads: For the SAE Institute London Administration and Coordination, We, the students of SAE London, are, through this letter, demanding the immediate reinstatement of 24-hour access to the studios at Bankstock. The reduct...
|88||2 890|| Enough lies about the death of Magdalena Zuk!
President: Andrzej Duda, To information: Prime Minister / Prime Minister: Beata Szydlo Minister of Justice / Attorney General: Zbigniew Ziobro Dear President, We the undersigned, ask The President of the Polish Repablic to take special care of all activities to clarify the circumstances of our countrywoman death, Magdaleny Żuk. We want to send a clear message to all authorities: We dem...
|81||81|| my son is suffering a mental health crisis and needs moving asap!!
my son marcus is 23 and is autistic and suffers from.bipolar disorder....since the 31st of august his mental health has deteriorated drastically due to his support changing and becoming unsuitable which in turn is hindering his recovery. I have followed every process i have been asked to to get him where he needs to be to feel safe and understood and still nothing even tho all the professionals co...
|81||859|| Stop selling Uggs in shoe shops (=mistreatment of animals)
Many shoe stores still sell UGGs. If you are against animal cruelty, you cannot approve nor promote these products. The shoe brand UGG uses Australian merino sheep. The shoes are made from the inside-out skin of the sheep. The animals are killed for their skin. The sheep are tied to their legs and their tails are cut off. They will also be castrated (both without anesthesia). http://bit.ly/19xg...
|80||81|| Call for FOOD FOR ALL at UJ
The EFF Student Command at the University of Johannesburg (APK Campus) recognises that first and second year students receiving NSFAS do not receive food allowances. Instead, they receive food from the Gift of the Givers (GoG), an on-campus NGO, a process which denies them their dignity because they stand in long lines, basically begging for unhealthy food. This is often very inconvenient because...
|78||78|| MOUNT PUMP TRACK
Help us persuade the Tauranga City Council to allow us use of land in the new ARATAKI RESERVE on HUIA STREET to create a playspace in the form of a MOUNT PUMP TRACK that will be a sealed all weather multi purpose facility catering to BMXers, Mountain Bikers, Skateboarders, Scooters and be suitable for use by kids from 3 years to young minded 68 year olds. With Mount Maunganui's growing population...
|65||66|| ARHC moet dinsdag 12 december ijsvrij krijgen!
Op maandag 11 december kreeg onze school alleen het 5e en 6e uur ijsvrij. Hier door zijn als nog veel mensen gevallen. Op dinsdag 12 december ligt er nog steeds sneeuw, maar wij willen geen ernstig letsel oplopen, of iets dergelijke. Voor leerlingen en docenten is het beter om een dagje thuis te blijven. Teken deze petitie en zorg voor een ijsvrije dag op het ARHC!...
|62||62|| FÖRBJUD MINKUPPFÖDNING
I Sverige föds sedan 2014 enbart minkar upp på pälsdjursfarmer för sin päls. Rävfarmningen fasades ut 2001 och 2014 stängde den sista chinchillafarmen, till följd av strängare regler för hållningen av djuren varför då inte förbjuda även uppfödning av mink? När den nuvarande djurskyddslagen (1988:534) ersatte den gamla, uttalades att kravet på att djuren ska kunna "bete sig naturligt" även gälld...
|59||61|| Suspicious Midas Share manipulation
I would like to seek everyone attention on that there is a possibilities of share manipulation of the Midas holdings that occurs during th period from 24th Nov till 8th Dec 2017. Till Date it was approximately that around $100million or around 60% has been wiped off from the company capitalisation We would like the relevant authority to do a through investigtion based on the following reason. 1) M...
|57||69|| Arrest Justin Trudeau and Liberal MPs for TREASON immediately.
Justin Trudeau, with the Liberal government, has conspired with known terrorist and former Nazi collaborator George Soros to sell Canada's Syrian migrant policy to 13 undisclosed countries. Soros's (Open Society Foundation) role on the world stage is: fund regime change and/or destabilize nations, fund terrorism and import unvetted Islamic economic migrants infiltrated by radical Islamic terrori...
|56||56|| We want cast from The 100 on Warsaw Comic Con in Poland!
We'll be seariously thankful if you could sgin this! This means a lot for us! You need to confirm it from your e-mail. Thank you so much, wish you all th best! ...
|56||56|| National Enquiry into the Qube 2 events at Station Pier
We are asking for members to sign this petition for a National Enquiry due to the termination of two workers standing up for the health and safety of not only themselves but also their colleagues who still work with the deadly diesel particulate emissions on a daily basis..We will be following up on how these two members were represented and the surrounding events which saw one member end up havin...
|56||8 609|| Act against hatred - Soros posters in Budapest
Act against hatred You, who are disgusted by the torrent of repugnant posters and billboards against György Soros scattered all over Hungary; you, who viscerally refuse all forms of hatred-mongering; you, who feel that Hungary's economic and social leaders have added this final affront to many previous ones and ultimately sunk below even the lowest acceptable level of human and political honour...
|55||55|| Fire Ben Mcadoo and get Eli Manning to start again
Ben Mcadoo has thrown everyone under the bus except himself for his own failure as a coach. Now, Eli Manning, the face of our franchise since 2004 and 2x super bowl champion and Super Bowl MVP has to take the blame. Let’s take a stand and get Eli his job back and show the organization and Eli that the fans have his back....
|52||846|| STOP THE SLAUGHTER OF PEOPLE WITH ALBINISM IN AFRICA
Stand with us Stop the slaughter of People with albinism in Africa Help us break the silent chain of body part trafficking NOW! In February 2015 in Geita, Tanzania, a one year old boy called Yohana was snatched from his mothers arms’. The attackers came in the middle of the night and took Yohana away, leaving his mother badly injured by a machete as she tried to protect him. Yohana’s completel...